Investigacion Ramon y Cajal. In our letter to him, we have explained that we are two artists who have been studying his "astonishing research," and that we are interested in his views on the relationship between humans and machines. José M.R. Delgado has written that he will be most happy to receive us at his home in Madrid.
Delgado's name is a constant on various conspiracy websites dedicated to the topic of mind control; those with names like The Government Psychiatric Torture Site, and Parascope. The Internet has in fact become the medium of conspiracy theorists. The network functions as an endless library where the very web structure lends itself to a conspiratorial frame of mind. The idea that every phenomenon and person can be connected to another phenomenon and person is the seed of the conspiracy theorist's claim to "make the connections between things," track the flow of power, and show how everything hangs together within some larger murky context.
Before traveling to Madrid, we get a hold of Physical Control of the Mind: Toward a Psychocivilized Society, the 1969 Delgado book most often cited on the Net. The book has has been gathering dust for 30 years at the university's psychology library: it has never been cracked open. It is a disturbing book, less because of its photo-graphs of animal experiments than because of the triumphal tone of the writing. Delgado discusses how we have managed to tame and civilize our surrounding nature. Now it is time to civilize our inner being. The scientist sees himself on the verge of a new era where humans will undergo "psycho-civilization" by linking their brains directly to machines.
Ramon y Cajal is the name on one of the two insignia referred to in Delgado's book. Cajal was a famous histologist who became the young Delgado's mentor and inspiration. In his acknowledgements, Delgado cites Cajal's telling claim that
It was at Madrid University that Delgado began his research on pain and pleasure as the means of behavior control. After World War II, he became the head of the Department of neuropsychiatry at Yale's medical school. In 1966, he became a professor in physiology. By that time, he had further developed the research of the Swiss physiologist and Nobel Prize winner Walter Rudolph Hess, Egas Moniz who had used electric stimulation to chart how different parts of the brain control different motor functions.
After a series of spectacular experiments on animals in Bermuda, Delgado wrote:
Using
electrostimulation in a group of gibbon apes,
Delgado
succeeded
in dismantling the usual power structure within the group. He gave a
female
ape with a low ranking a control box connected to electrodes that were
implanted in the group's alpha male, and the female learned to use the
box to turn the alpha male on and off at will.
The electrodes were
inserted into the ape's brain and
connected to an
instrument that Delgado called the stimoceiver.
The stimoceiver was an
ideal instrument
for two-way communication. Researchers could affect
and
at the same time register activity in the brain. From earlier
prototypes
where the lab animals were connected with wires, a remote control model
was later developed that could send and receive signals over FM waves.
The device was developed from the telemetric equipment used to send
signals
to and from astronauts in space.
The taxi lets us out
in an upscale suburb of Madrid
where a
light rain
is falling on the brick houses. A church service has just finished and
people in Burberry clothes are streaming out of a strange concrete
church.
At the entrance of the apartment building where Delgado lives, we are
met
by a fashionable and exuberant American woman of indeterminable age.
The
woman, who is Delgado's wife, talks nonstop in the elevator that opens
directly into the apartment. The apartment is decorated in a fussy,
bourgeois
style. If it were not such a bleak day, the view would extend all the
way
to the Pardo Mountains. Delgado gives us a very cordial welcome. He is
a proper old gentleman with sharp, intelligent eyes.
Delgado says that he
has had a nightmare about our visit
and
woke up
crying in the middle of the night. In the dream, we had showed up
barefoot
and in short sleeve shirts and had proceeded to gulp down all of his
meringues.
An hour later, we are seated at the marble table in his dining room and
are served meringues and strawberry tarts after a large meal. We do not
want to have more than one meringue each.
In a CNN special from
1985 called "Electro-magnetic Weapons
and Mind
Control," the reporter claims that Delgado's experiments
were limited
to
animals. Nor is there anything in the texts on the various websites
that
indicates how far Delgado went in his research. His experiments on
humans
seem to have fallen into a strange collective amnesia. But anyone can
walk
into any well-stocked American medical library and take out Delgado's
own
reports and articles on the subject. There we can find his own candid,
open descriptions of how he moved on from experimenting on animals to
humans.In
an article called Radio Control Behavior
in the February 1969 issue
of The
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, Delgado, Dr. Mark, and
several
other colleagues describe what was the first clinical use of Intracerebral
Radio Stimulation (IRS) on a human being. The stimoceiver itself only
weighed
70 grams and was held fast by a bandage. One of the patients hid her
stimoceiver
with a wig because the experiments lasted days or weeks. The patients
were
scrutinized thoroughly. Everything they said was taped, their EEG was
recorded,
and they were photographed at regular intervals in order to document
changes
in their facial expressions.
In one of the
article's photographs, we see two of the
subjects engaged
in "spontaneous activity." They are both girls with bandages over their
heads. The girl in the background is holding something to her mouth,
perhaps
a harmonica. The other girl is bent over a guitar. Delgado's colleague,
Dr. Mark, is smiling at them. Mark had already achieved some
notoriety
at this time by claiming that all anti-social behavior is caused by
brain
damage. His recommendation had been the mass scanning of the American
population
in order to detect such damage in time and "correct" it.
Delgado and Mark's
article offers short descriptions of
the
patients
who have had the device affixed to their brain. A black
fourteen-year-old
girl on the border of developmental disability who grew up in a foster
home suddenly goes into a fury that leads to the death of her two
stepsisters.
A thirty-five-year old white industrial designer who ends up killing
his
wife and children flies into a rage when other motorists try to
overtake
him and he chases them and tries to run them off the road. Their
aggressive
behavior is supposed to be registered by the stimoceiver in the way a
seismograph
registers the earth's tremors and the same stimoceiver is then to "turn
them off" via the FM transmitter.
Delgado bombards us
with a steady stream of anecdotes,
scientific comments,
and provocative rhetorical questions that are only interrupted by
occasional
tender comments directed to his wife. He tells of his work at the Ramon
y Cajal Institute in the 1930s. In order to save a few
paltry
pennies,
he would take a short cut through the zoo on his way to and from work.
He would wander through the zoo alone at dawn and dusk and would hear
lions
and tigers roaring in this jungle in the city. After the War, he came
to
conquer nature in his own way in Bermuda. Even his wife was delighted
to
see the alpha male gibbon collapse when the underlings pushed the
control
lever.
One of the most
important reasons why we wanted to meet
Delgado is that
we imagined him and his activities as belonging
to a borderland between
fiction and reality, between science and madness. People in psychotic
states
of mind often feel themselves controlled by foreign voices or spend
their
lives trying to prove that they have had a transmitter implanted inside
their skulls that dictates their actions and thoughts all day and
night.
We ask Delgado what he thinks of the fact that his research provides a
realistic edge to such fantasies.
He answers that he
has on several occasions been
contacted by
strangers
who say they want to have their implants removed and also that he has
been
sued by people he has never seen. Delgado is silent about the article
that
appeared in the Spanish monthly magazine Tiempo
last year,
where
he was interviewed about exactly such accusations. The Tiempo
reporter
claimed that Delgado has ties with the Spanish secret police.
Delgado stretches out
after the strawberry tarts. He has
come
to think
of a case in Pittsburg in the 1950s where a robber was offered a milder
sentence in exchange for being lobotomized.
It was Koskoff who carried out
the lobotomy on the robber. The patient
was quiet for a while after the operation but then reverted to carrying
out robberies again. In despair over his own unreliability, he decided
to take his own life. He wrote a suicide note addressed to Dr. Koskoff:
Delgado's wife puts
her arm on his shoulder and says
The comment makes us both look
away.
A moment later, we
are sitting on the sofa. Delgado
admits
that not
one useful application of the stimoceiver has come out of his research.
He says all of this without a
trace of
bitterness, as if in
passing.
We are surprised by
his casual attitude toward the
stimoceiver, which
in the 1960s and 70s was heralded as a great contribution to science.
To
demonstrate the power of their invention, Delgado and his colleagues
orchestrated
violent scenes in the lab. In her book, The Brain Changers:
Scientists
and the New Mind Control, Maya Pine describes a film where
Dr. Mark
attaches a stimoceiver to an electrode in a woman's brain. As
the film opens, the patient, a rather
attractive young
woman, is seen playing the guitar and singing Puff, the Magic Dragon.
A psychiatrist sits a few feet away. She seems undisturbed by the
bandages
that cover her head like a tight hood, from her forehead to the back of
her neck. Then a mild electric current is sent from another room,
stimulating
one of the electrodes in her right amygdala. Immediately, she stops
singing,
the brainwave tracings from her amygdala begin to show spikes, a sign
of
seizure activity. She stares blankly ahead. Suddenly she grabs her
guitar
and smashes it against the wall, narrowly missing the psychiatrist's
head.2
The same incident was
described in one of Delgado's own
articles. This
experiment was repeated three days in a row.
If there were any
problems with the experiments for
Delgado,
these were
not ethical in nature but technical. How do you replicate the lab
situation
in society? How do you cut off the electricity to the stimoceiver? How
do you avoid scarring and inflammation where the stimoceiver enters the
brain? But the problems did not provoke any doubts about the supposed
success
of the stimoceiver. In the long run, the technique could be used to
make
people happy from a distance.
we ask
him.
To our
surprise, he responds indignantly that he has yet to do so.
Delgado's pragmatism does another
pirouette and we are beginning to
have
trouble following him.
Delgado pours coffee
with his trembling hands. Spanish
guitar
music
from the stereo fills the silence. We look together through the three
recent
collection of essays that Delgado has placed in front of us. Their
publication
dates range from 1979 up to this year. There is no emphasis on
neurophysiology
in any of them. Instead, they address questions of learning and
upbringing
from a more general psychological point of view.
Until the end of the
70s, Delgado and his colleagues
were
considered
conquerors of an unknown territory, a wild and expansive jungle, the
landscape
of the brain and the soul. Apparently Delgado never got very far into
the
jungle, which proved to be much too thick and impenetrable. He has
apparently
retired without any regrets. He has instead started to cultivate his
own
garden. "My new book is
going to be called The
Education of
My
Grandchildren
and Myself."
We ask if it is
possible to learn to interpret the
electrical
language
of the brain and mention the Swedish science journalist Göran
Frankel's
interview with Delgado back in 1977.3
In the interview
Delgado claims that it is only a
question of time
before
we connect the brain directly into computers that can communicate with
the brain's electrical language.
Delgado makes a
dismissive gesture and looks at us as if
we
are numskulls.
"It is impossible to
decode the brain's language. We can obviously
manipulate
different forms of electrical activity but what does that prove?"
When
we ask him about his colleague, Dr. Robert G. Heath,
who claimed to be
able to cure schizophrenic patients with electrostimulation, Delgado
breaks
into a patronizing smile and says,
We lead him to a
discussion of his own patients. Delgado
interrupts
us:
For a moment, we wonder
if we'll have to take out one of his own scientific articles and hold
it
in front of him as evidence. We start to look for our file with
hundreds
of medical reports and articles.
In one of the Yale
reports in our file, there is a
description
of an
experiment on an epileptic mental patient. The report states that the
woman
has been in asylums for a long time, she is worried about her daughter,
and suffers from economic hardship. Electrodes measuring 12 centimeters
have been stuck into her brain, 5 centimeters of them inside the brain
tissue. She is interviewed while being given periodic electrical
stimulation.
The woman is tossed between various emotional states and finds that
strange
words are coming to her mind. She experiences pain and sexual desire.
At
the end of the interview, she becomes flirty and her language becomes
coarse,
only to be ashamed later and ask to be excused for words that she felt
had come to her from outside. The
woman has been transformed into a
speaking
doll that unwillingly gives voice to her brain's every whim.
Delgado, who had
previously been so flattered by two
artists
being interested
in his work, now seems to be looking at us with new eyes. Who are we?
And
what do we want? His tone is short and sharp. The temperature in the
apartment
has dropped a few degrees. In Physical
Control of the Mind,
Delgado proudly sums
up how
he has
With this in
mind,
we ask him what therapeutic results came from these experiments.
He looks at the clock
and says that we only have five
minutes
left.
But we do not want to abandon our questions about the patients. What
happened
to them? How long were the implants in their brains? Delgado now
becomes
somewhat vague. He says that it was other researchers that left the
implants
in for a long time, not him or Dr. Heath, and he does not recall which
patients it was. The electrodes were taken out of his own patients
after
a couple of days and did not cause any injuries.
When Delgado spoke in
the 60s of "the precise
interface
between brain
and machine," it gave rise to a number of far-fetched
military visions.
His research was also mainly funded by military institutions such as
the Office of Naval Research
and the Air Force
AeroMedical Research
Laboratory.
In the US, the CIA
and government research in (and use
of)
different
means of behavior control was made public in a series of congressional
hearings in 1974 as well as in a Senate investigation three years
later.
Witnesses offered a glimpse of the CIA's astonishing experiments in the
so-called MK-Ultra program. The list of MK-Ultra experiments is like a
group photo of the extended family of behavioral technologies:
hypnosis,
drugs, psychological testing, sleep research, brain research,
electromagnetism,
lie detection. The specific operations had very imaginative names: Sleeping
Beauty, Project Pandora, Woodpecker, Memorandum for the
record:Artichoke, Operation Midnight
Climax, Project
Pandora Radio Remote Brain Manipulation.
The CIA arranged for
apes to be brought to the embassy.
When
the apes
were examined after a period of being radiated, it was discovered that
they had undergone changes in their chromosomes and blood. The
personnel
at the embassy was later reported to have increased white blood cell
counts
of up to 40 percent. The Boston Globe reported
that
the
ambassador
himself suffered not only from bloody eyes and chronic headaches but
also
from a blood disease resembling leukemia.
We take up Delgado's
research on electromagnetic fields
and
their effect
on people.
We understand now
that Delgado thinks the meeting ought
to
come to an
end. We ask him about Project Pandora
and he confirms the story of the Moscow Signal (*) without
any hesitation but he denies being involved in
the
operation.
In 1974 Delgado
testified in front of Congress at the
MK-Ultra
hearings
and made his views very clear:
When we confront him with this statement, he falls silent for a second. His crystal-clear memory of a moment ago suddenly evaporates. A fog sweeps in, the words become hard to get out. He does not recall ever being called to Congress. And he has no desire to acknowledge the kinds of statements we have just mentioned. For a second, Delgado becomes a very old and fragile man. But in the next moment, he is standing up straight again and has shaken off all these unpleasantries. Now he is in a hurry. He has to meet his sick sister-in-law. We try to secure a second meeting but he is evasive and talks about the vagaries of the weather and trips to his country house. Out the door in a cloud of cigar smoke, the taxi takes us back to Madrid.
Fredrik Ekman is a lyricist and writer based in Stockholm
Jos Delgado books
1 José M. R. Delgado, Physical Control of the Mind: Toward a Psychocivilized Society (New York: Harper & Row, 1969), p. xix.
2 La felicidad (Spanish Edition) [Paperback]
3 Behavioral Neurochemistry: Proceedings by Jose Manuel Rodrigue Delgado, F. V. Defeudis
4 Maya Pines, The Brain-Changers (London: Allen Lane, 1974), p. 197.
5 The interview is available in Frankel's book Ingenjörstrupper i hjärnan (Stockholm: 1979).
6 José M.R. Delgado, Congressional Record, nr. 26, vol. 118, 1974.
CORRECTIONS (29 November 2014)
Magnus Bärtås is an artist and writer based in Stockholm. Bärtås has previously been on the editorial board of the Swedish magazines 90TAL and Index. He teaches at the University College of Arts and Crafts in Stockholm and is also a lecturer and examiner at the art colleges in Umeå and Gothenburg.
Uno degli scienziati più
controversi, divenuto col passare degli anni un “mostro” assoluto ma
sempre più nebuloso nella mitologia del XX° secolo, è
José Delgado. Oggi i vari saggi e le relazioni sui nuovi
esperimenti citano raramente Delgado, che è divenuto una sorta
di paria della scienza a causa delle sue posizioni troppo “estremiste”
e “destrorse” negli anni ’70. Da Bizzarro Bazar